Ryuuza
Age : 32 Posts : 381
| Subject: Re: Saundo Clan {WiP} Fri 25 Mar 2011, 7:47 pm | |
| Before you get any further than this, sound is not a bloodline limit. |
|
Tony
Age : 28 Posts : 701
| Subject: Re: Saundo Clan {WiP} Fri 25 Mar 2011, 11:30 pm | |
| Yea... not too familiar with terminology such as "bloodline LIMIT", speak on my terms, please? |
|
Ryuuza
Age : 32 Posts : 381
| Subject: Re: Saundo Clan {WiP} Sat 26 Mar 2011, 3:39 am | |
| *sighs* I really hope you're not kidding here.
Kekkei genkai (Literally meaning "a technique limited to inheritance by blood" or "Bloodline Limit") |
|
Elder Sage
Age : 31 Posts : 1118
| Subject: Re: Saundo Clan {WiP} Sat 26 Mar 2011, 3:53 am | |
| - Quote :
- Before you get any further than this, sound is not a bloodline limit.
That is somewhat false. Sound manipulation may be inaccessible from a elemental combination perspective, but can however be the result in a unique yin/yang release which his clan may specialize in using sound with. It may not be a kekkei genkai per-say, but a clan can specialize in it. |
|
Ryuuza
Age : 32 Posts : 381
| Subject: Re: Saundo Clan {WiP} Sat 26 Mar 2011, 4:01 am | |
| A kekkei genkai implies that said abilities and jutsu cannot be copied. Sound can most certainly be copied. I don't care if the clan specializes it, its not a kekkei genkai.
|
|
Aries
Age : 36 Posts : 1004
| Subject: Re: Saundo Clan {WiP} Sat 26 Mar 2011, 4:04 am | |
| But it's a clan trait much like the Nara clan...Their technique can be taught out of their clan...it's not a KKG but it surely is their clan technique only specialized by them.
|
|
Caranore
Age : 35 Posts : 1492
| Subject: Re: Saundo Clan {WiP} Sat 26 Mar 2011, 4:18 am | |
| Even though this is not my clan, I would like to request the above posts not relating to this clan posted by myself or other members not in the process of making said clan be removed.
This was also brought up by Hugh by the way, and Sound, according to him, is a generalized jutsu concept, but the clan could specialize in a certain way of utilizing the Sound jutsu.
As another note, Aries, sadly, is right. A Kekkai Genkai, or bloodline limit, is something like Uchiha clan, which is related directly to the genetics of a certain clan. The Nara, Yamanaka, Akimichi, Inuzuka, Aburame are all secret jutsu based clans, each one having a unique and different circumstance.
Example: Someone CAN steal a dog from an Inuzuka, and utilize the clans jutsu if they manage to get the jutsu scroll. Someone can also steal an Aburame hive from the compound, and if they, again, have the scroll, be able to gain the ability to use the Aburame bugs, etc.
But, like I said above, sound is a generalized jutsu concept. If this was made into the only clan that could use sound, any other jutsu relating to sound, such as a Kin's genjutsu from the Chuunin Exams, would be unavailable to others. The only way for this clan to work, again like I stated above, would be to have a specific way of utilizing the sound jutsu.
After reading this please follow my first request and delete anything not related to clan modding. |
|
Elder Sage
Age : 31 Posts : 1118
| Subject: Re: Saundo Clan {WiP} Sat 26 Mar 2011, 4:21 am | |
| Both of you are correct, and there's an easy solution.
Tony, simply move your Sound Manipulation into your clan's "Signature Traits' category so it'll be a clan specialization rather than a kkg. Win/Win.
Pardon us for our little debate on your application Tony. Please feel free to continue with your clan.
|
|
Sponsored content
| Subject: Re: Saundo Clan {WiP} | |
| |
|