Could I change?

Posts : 1187

I was just wondering if I would be able to eventually change my weaponry specs for short and mid to short and long? I would give up all my mid ranged weapons I just really want to have long ranged weapons instead.

Posts : 1729

inb4 "Nope."

But yeah, no, most likely not. While a seemingly minor change, it's still effectively changing a specialty, which is a big no-no. Or otherwise it'll just be argued as "unfair," since users of other specialties wouldn't be able to achieve similar effects, like how it got nixed in the sub-spec system for a weaponry user to learn long-range from a long-range specialist and "improve" their weaponry spec.

Age : 37 Posts : 2201

Quote :: While a seemingly minor change, it's still effectively changing a specialty, which is a big no-no. Or otherwise it'll just be argued as "unfair," since users of other specialties wouldn't be able to achieve similar effects, like how it got nixed in the sub-spec system for a weaponry user to learn long-range from a long-range specialist and "improve" their weaponry spec.

People cannot change their specialties, it is as simple as that. Changing a range = changing the specialty even if it's just a small part of it.

That's at least how I see this, I don't know if the rest of the staff will agree.

Age : 31 Posts : 471

Quote :: While a seemingly minor change, it's still effectively changing a specialty, which is a big no-no. Or otherwise it'll just be argued as "unfair," since users of other specialties wouldn't be able to achieve similar effects, like how it got nixed in the sub-spec system for a weaponry user to learn long-range from a long-range specialist and "improve" their weaponry spec.

Quote :: People cannot change their specialties, it is as simple as that. Changing a range = changing the specialty even if it's just a small part of it.

Posts : 182

Posts : 1729

Mors Atra wrote:: inb4 "Nope."

But yeah, no, most likely not. While a seemingly minor change, it's still effectively changing a specialty, which is a big no-no. Or otherwise it'll just be argued as "unfair," since users of other specialties wouldn't be able to achieve similar effects, like how it got nixed in the sub-spec system for a weaponry user to learn long-range from a long-range specialist and "improve" their weaponry spec.

Age : 29 Posts : 3145

(just getting that post count up)

Posts : 363

Unlike the cold-hearted folks who know nothing more to say than no, I would say it would depend how long your character has been allowed. I would totally allow a new Genin who in reflection after being approved has realized he's made a grave error, misread something, or was told the Weapon he actually wanted was a different range than he was specializing in...

However, you're an experienced Genin, so I expect your character has around longer, so I too would hesitate to allow the change.

Posts : 182

Idk why this hasnt been solved and locked yet.

Age : 31 Posts : 471

Mostly because we don't know if Noisy has read his answers yet, and hasn't had the chance to either say he understands or provide reasons for disagreeing.

Age : 31 Posts : 8965

Shiro wrote:: Unlike the cold-hearted folks who know nothing more to say than no, I would say it would depend how long your character has been allowed. I would totally allow a new Genin who in reflection after being approved has realized he's made a grave error, misread something, or was told the Weapon he actually wanted was a different range than he was specializing in...

However, you're an experienced Genin, so I expect your character has around longer, so I too would hesitate to allow the change.

Thank you! This is what I was about to post. Can I solve this now so everybody stops spamming cookie monsters?

Posts : 1187

True sorry I didn't know you were waiting for me. Ok I understand thank you.

Age : 32 Posts : 683

Age : 37 Posts : 2201

Solved.